Now that I have gone to 14 different Macarooneries, I consider myself quite the connaisseur. I didn’t want to eat all 20 macaroons at once, and so I spaced my eating of them over a week. Hence, I really enjoyed, and analyzed the flavors of each macaroon.
I think if I had just bought a macaroon at a time, without the wonderful serendipity of macaroon day, I wouldn’t have learned nearly as much about my macaroon palette!
So, what did I think?
Cognac Champagne: The first macaroon I ate of the macaroon day, this one I didn’t even wait until I got home! This one was quite small and from Dalloyau. Not too pleased with that store in general - the staff didn’t know their stuff, and it wasn’t a great experience. The macaroon was light and flaky but tasted more like vanilla than either of the alcohols they said were inside.
Plum: From Jean Paul Hevin, this had a very subtle flavor, but I found that the chocolate overpowered the plum flavor. It was so rich, that maybe the plum should have paired with a less intense flavor? I give it a B
Chocolate orange gingembre (Jean Paul Hevin): Sweet flavor but hard to taste chocolate and orange. This macaroon was nice, but really didn’t make an impression with me. B
Pamplemousse- This grapefruit macaroon from Jean Paul Hevin angy inside! But doesn’t quite remind me if hrapfruit. If I didn’t know aleesdy, i wouldnt Have guessed this flavor. The texture of the filling is really nice, but the cookie part is a but crunchy. B+
Yuzu’in: A Japanese inspired fruity and spicy macaroon from JPH. It had a spicy and fruity flavor at the same time, but it had that weird taste that all the JP Hevin macaroons have.. almost bitter? Saving grace was that it had a reeeally good texture on this one though, creamy texture and a slightly crunchy cookie part. A
Chocolate American: Another weird JP Hevin taste. The chocolate must be a milk/dark chocolate mix and there was a crunch yellow topping. I was too busy trying to analyze what it was made of, and what made it taste so weird to enjoy what little of the macaroon that was enjoyable. C
Creme-brûlée: Actually delicious, and entirely perfect. JPH perfectly captured the flavor of a Creme brûlée and the texture was wonderful! A
Citron’in: This one tasted exactly like key lime pie!! It was so good I gobbled it up in an instant, not even waiting like usual to pause in between bites! A
Passion’in: I had no idea with what was inside this one. I REALLY DIDN’T LIKE IT. It was bitter, not at all like passion fruit, if that was what they were trying to recreate. I could taste the tanginess of the fruit but it clashed with the sweetness of the cookie. C-
Piña colada: Only the center tasted like a piña colada .. The cookie part was also too soft. Sweet in general but didn’t leave an impression.. B
Thé japonaise: This one was from a japanese patisserie/macaronerie that was participating in the macaroon day. It had a really subtle flavor, earthy texture, especially with the little toppings of twigs and herbs!! It was nothing like drinking tea but as I was sitting outside in the sunshine while I ate it, I was perfectly okay that it wasn’t the same! B+
Chocolate mangue: The filling is great! I can really tell they used high quality mangos and the flavor comes through, but the chocolate on the cookie isnt doing anything for me. Only the last bite I had with all cookie no filling tasted remotely like chocolate, but on the whole it was a really nice tasting macaroon! A
Carmel apple- JP Hevin required this one as part of the three that they gave you, so I had multiple times to try this one. It was nice but it just doesn’t stand out. I could eat a box of them without thinking. The indisde tastes more like compote than like carmel or apple . B
Saving the best for last, I began to move on to the Pierre Hermé macaroons! I consider Pierre Hermé to be the best macaroonerie in Paris - and the price shows it. At 1€60 for each macaroon, it is a real treat!
Huile d’olive: This macaroon is made of olive oil and mandarin oranges. But, I was kind of disappointed! It had a light taste, and doesn’t really taste like olive oil or mandarin orange - just sweet. There were multiple different types of filling - bits of orange, olive oil, etc. but I felt the taste of the orange in the very center of the filling. B+
Montebello: A VERY pretty macaroon, with framboise (raspberry!)and pistachio. Can’t really taste the pistachio- framboise overpowers. The inside bite is like eating raspberry jam. B
Magador: Chocolate filling and passion fruit! Much better than other passion fruit one I had. This combo is better, creating a better balance of sweet and tart. A
Fortunella: I don’t know what kumquats taste like when not in a macaroon, but this one had a texture and taste much more of a vegetable or fruit. The filling was not just a cream or mousse but there was actually a whole piece of kumquat in my macaroon! I’m not really sure I LIKE the texture of kumquats, but it was interesting! The aniseed that was also in the macaroon gave it a bit of spice. B
Pietra: Made of noisette (what Nutella is made out of) and pralines, this was delicious, but how could it not be! It was a little dry, and a bit crunchy. The flavor of the noisette was delicious, but it drowned of the flavor of the pralines a bit too much. I did notice the praline croustillant, in that there was a very crunchy aspect that I wasn’t so fond of. It was delicious overall. B+/A
Chocolate foie gras: I knew when I picked this I was taking a risk, but this is crazy! Chocolate flavor strong at first and then the foie grad flavor was really overwhelming!! The last few bites were like being at dinner - I wanted a baguette to go along with it! Probably not my first choice in macaroon treats - maybe for a during dinner macaroon? B-
So what was my favorite? I would probably say stick with chocolate flavors, or pure fruit flavors. Mixing is inventive and can lead to some interesting tastes, but the classics come from flavors like noisette, creme brûlée, etc. Although, my favorite fall back will always be framboise - raspberry!
So happy macaroon tasting to you! Go out there and find YOUR favorite flavor! (To Bobby and Gaby - what was your favorite?!?) I hope to make some when I am back in the states, even though it is pretty difficult, it would totally be worth it for those little nuggets of deliciousness!